Payton Tolle, 81 Live - MLB the Show 26
Buy
Loading...
Sell
Loading...
Sales/hr
Loading...
Date Added
3-12-26
Where to Get
Drop Rate
Approximately 1 in 1176 Packs
Quirks - 0
No Quirks
Other Versions
Payton Tolle 94 Mural
Payton Tolle 99 2026 Finest

Player Bio

common Hitting Hitting
common Defense Defense
Overall
81
Position
SP
Tendency
Bats
L
Throws
L
Team
Number
70
Weight
250
Height
6'6"
Age
23
Born
Oklahoma

Attributes

Parallel & Captain Boosts

Select a Parallel Level to filter the mods to that level.

Total Attributes

Hitter Total
634
Pitcher Total
839
Overall Total
1473

Pitches

4-Seam Fastball #1 64% usage
Rating
74
Speed
97
Break
63
Cutter #2 13% usage
Rating
58
Speed
90
Break
69
Slider #3 10% usage
Rating
64
Speed
89
Break
68
Circle Change #4 7% usage
Rating
53
Speed
88
Break
62
Curveball #5 6% usage
Rating
63
Speed
83
Break
65

Pitching

H/9 Right
78
H/9 Left
63
K/9 Right
78
K/9 Left
58
Control
52
Pitch Clutch
65
Stamina
83
Velocity
87
Break
69
Stuff
65
HR/9
67
BB/9
74

Fielding

Fielding
58
Arm Strength
60
Arm Accuracy
64
Reaction Left
64
Reaction Right
64
Reaction Fwd
64
Reaction Back
64
Durability
82

Speed

Speed
29
Stealing
6
Baserunning
5

Payton Tolle MLB The Show 26 Card Breakdown

This is the Live card for Payton Tolle, featured in MLB The Show 26. He's a 81 Overall Gold card primarily playing SP.

Released 7 months ago, Payton Tolle with a drop rate of approximately 1 in 1176 MLB The Show packs.

He currently holds the #389 rank among 726 starting pitchers.

On the mound, Payton Tolle exhibits decent H/9 Right with a 78 rating and modest H/9 Left with a 63 rating, competent K/9 Right with a 78 rating and below average K/9 Left with a 58 rating, and competent BB/9 with a 74 rating. With runners threatening, his Pitching Clutch rating of 65 shows modest performance. His overall pitching profile is defined by below average control with a Control rating of 52, average velocity with a Velocity rating of 87, and average break with a Break rating of 69. As a starting pitcher, his stamina is average with a rating of 83.

He utilizes a 5-pitch mix, spearheaded by a 4-Seam Fastball, complemented by a Cutter.

In the field, Payton Tolle is a solid defender. His key defensive attributes are 58 Fielding, 60 Arm Strength, 64 Reaction Left, 64 Reaction Right, 64 Reaction Fwd, 64 Reaction Back.

Payton Tolle is a 23-year-old player from Oklahoma, standing 6'6" tall and weighing 250 lbs. He currently plays for the Red Sox, batting Left-handed and throwing Left-handed.

Other available versions for Payton Tolle include: Mural (94 Diamond),2026 Finest (99 Red Diamond).