Payton Tolle

This is the 2026 Finest card for Payton Tolle, featured in MLB The Show 26. He's a 99 Overall Red Diamond card primarily playing SP.

Released 17 hours ago, Payton Tolle is a great free option from the 2026 Finest 1 Program.

He currently holds the #10 rank among 709 starting pitchers.

On the mound, Payton Tolle exhibits elite H/9 Right with a 123 rating and great H/9 Left with a 110 rating, outstanding K/9 Right with a 120 rating and very strong K/9 Left with a 101 rating, and great BB/9 with a 114 rating. With runners threatening, his Pitching Clutch rating of 110 shows very strong performance. His overall pitching profile is defined by outstanding control with a Control rating of 99, top-tier velocity with a Velocity rating of 99, and outstanding break with a Break rating of 99. As a starting pitcher, his stamina is impressive with a rating of 105.

His repertoire includes the valuable Sinker/Cutter combination. He utilizes a 5-pitch mix, spearheaded by a 4-Seam Fastball, complemented by a Sinker. Key pitches include: His Sinker boasts high velocity and sharp break with excellent command and his Cutter exhibits considerable movement with excellent command.

In the field, Payton Tolle is a average defender. His key defensive attributes are 58 Fielding, 60 Arm Strength, 64 Reaction Left, 64 Reaction Right, 64 Reaction Fwd, 64 Reaction Back.

Payton Tolle is a 23-year-old player from Oklahoma, standing 6'6" tall and weighing 250 lbs. He currently plays for the Red Sox, batting Left-handed and throwing Left-handed.

Active Quirks for Payton Tolle: Homebody, Night Player, Break Outlier.

Other available versions for Payton Tolle include: Live (79 Silver),Mural (94 Diamond).