Captain Andy Pettitte info and eligible players - MLB The Show 26

Andy Pettitte

SP

CORE | Jolt | Yankees

Not Sellable

Date Added

3-12-26

Where to Get

• Yankees Team Affinity

Players from the New York Yankees

• Tier 1 Requires 5 Pitchers
• +2 H/9 Right
• +2 H/9 Left
• +2 K/9 Right
• +2 K/9 Left

• Tier 2 Requires 10 Pitchers
• +4 H/9 Right
• +4 H/9 Left
• +4 K/9 Right
• +4 K/9 Left

• Tier 3 Requires 15 Pitchers
• +6 H/9 Right
• +6 H/9 Left
• +6 K/9 Right
• +6 K/9 Left

88

Andy Pettitte

Jolt | yankees

L/L SP

C R 8

C L 6

P R 7

P L 4

VIS 6

CLU 7

FLD 74

SPD 42

 

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FBCutter Cutter12-6 Curve 12-6Circle Change Circ-ChSinker Sinker

88

Austin Wells

World Baseball Classic | yankees

L/R C

C R 73

C L 76

P R 94

P L 80

VIS 76

CLU 79

FLD 93

SPD 45

 

88

Derek Jeter

Jolt | yankees

R/R SS

C R 95

C L 109

P R 52

P L 60

VIS 88

CLU 80

FLD 72

SPD 72

 

87

Whitey Ford

St. Patrick's Day | yankees

L/L SP

Buy 3,687

Sell 2,250

C R 14

C L 19

P R 13

P L 8

VIS 11

CLU 8

FLD 73

SPD 30

 

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FBSlider SliderChangeup ChangeSinker SinkerCurveball Curve

87

Aaron Judge

World Baseball Classic | yankees

R/R RF CF

Buy 3,543

Sell 2,550

C R 72

C L 78

P R 89

P L 104

VIS 40

CLU 74

FLD 75

SPD 46

 

87

Cam Schlittler

Live | yankees

R/R SP

Buy 5,242

Sell 4,505

C R 6

C L 7

P R 6

P L 7

VIS 5

CLU 8

FLD 46

SPD 38

 

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FBCutter CutterCurveball CurveSinker SinkerSweeper Sweep

87

Jazz Chisholm Jr.

World Baseball Classic | yankees

L/R 2B 3B

Buy 4,799

Sell 3,001

C R 71

C L 74

P R 107

P L 81

VIS 55

CLU 52

FLD 87

SPD 65

 

85

Harrison Cohen

World Baseball Classic | yankees

R/R RP

Buy 1,887

Sell 1,500

C R 2

C L 6

P R 4

P L 8

VIS 4

CLU 5

FLD 56

SPD 38

 

Cutter CutterCircle Change Circ-Ch4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FBSlider Slider

85

Ben Rice

Live | yankees

L/R 1B C

Buy 3,477

Sell 3,000

C R 78

C L 52

P R 105

P L 84

VIS 61

CLU 68

FLD 61

SPD 57

 

85

Cody Bellinger

Live | yankees

L/L LF 1B, CF, RF

Buy 3,486

Sell 3,000

C R 63

C L 86

P R 61

P L 61

VIS 82

CLU 102

FLD 78

SPD 70

 

85

José Caballero

World Baseball Classic | yankees

R/R SS 2B, 3B, LF, CF, RF

Buy 1,900

Sell 1,500

C R 70

C L 80

P R 50

P L 78

VIS 57

CLU 85

FLD 91

SPD 81

 

85

Max Fried

Live | yankees

L/L SP

Buy 3,475

Sell 3,000

C R 42

C L 49

P R 15

P L 18

VIS 40

CLU 44

FLD 90

SPD 35

 

Cutter CutterSinker SinkerCurveball Curve4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FBSweeper Sweep

84

Fernando Cruz

World Baseball Classic | yankees

R/R RP

C R 3

C L 5

P R 4

P L 8

VIS 3

CLU 3

FLD 55

SPD 39

 

Splitter Split4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FBSinker SinkerSlider Slider

83

Elmer Rodriguez

World Baseball Classic | yankees

L/R SP

Buy 2,111

Sell 636

C R 5

C L 7

P R 4

P L 6

VIS 7

CLU 8

FLD 42

SPD 44

 

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FBSinker SinkerCutter CutterSlider SliderCircle Change Circ-Ch

83

Bernie Williams

Breakout | yankees

S/R CF

C R 90

C L 87

P R 38

P L 75

VIS 70

CLU 92

FLD 75

SPD 75

 

83

Clay Holmes

All-Star | yankees

R/R CP

C R 0

C L 0

P R 0

P L 0

VIS 0

CLU 0

FLD 55

SPD 29

 

Sinker SinkerSlider SliderSweeper Sweep4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

82

Camilo Doval

World Baseball Classic | yankees

R/R RP

Buy 1,238

Sell 459

C R 0

C L 0

P R 0

P L 0

VIS 2

CLU 0

FLD 33

SPD 34

 

Slider SliderCutter CutterSinker Sinker

81

Carlos Rodón

Live | yankees

L/L SP

Buy 656

Sell 600

C R 0

C L 0

P R 0

P L 0

VIS 4

CLU 0

FLD 58

SPD 25

 

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FBSlider SliderCircle Change Circ-ChSinker SinkerCurveball Curve

81

Gerrit Cole

Live | yankees

R/R SP

Buy 668

Sell 600

C R 22

C L 22

P R 29

P L 29

VIS 15

CLU 22

FLD 29

SPD 25

 

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FBKnuckle-curve Kn-CrvCutter CutterSlider SliderCircle Change Circ-Ch

80

Aaron Judge

Topps Now | yankees

R/R RF

C R 52

C L 48

P R 91

P L 86

VIS 45

CLU 57

FLD 74

SPD 56