Captain Andy Pettitte info and eligible players - MLB The Show 26

Andy Pettitte

SP

CORE | Jolt | Yankees

Not Sellable

Date Added

3-12-26

Where to Get

• Yankees Team Affinity

Players from the New York Yankees

• Tier 1 Requires 5 Pitchers
• +2 H/9 Right
• +2 H/9 Left
• +2 K/9 Right
• +2 K/9 Left

• Tier 2 Requires 10 Pitchers
• +4 H/9 Right
• +4 H/9 Left
• +4 K/9 Right
• +4 K/9 Left

• Tier 3 Requires 15 Pitchers
• +6 H/9 Right
• +6 H/9 Left
• +6 K/9 Right
• +6 K/9 Left

93

Lou Gehrig

Vintage | yankees

L/L 1B

C R 101

C L 90

P R 81

P L 76

VIS 90

CLU 100

FLD 75

SPD 56

 

93

Cam Schlittler

Topps Now | yankees

R/R SP

C R 6

C L 7

P R 6

P L 7

VIS 5

CLU 8

FLD 46

SPD 38

 

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FBCutter CutterSinker SinkerCurveball CurveSlider Slider

93

Ben Rice

Spotlight | yankees

L/R 1B C

C R 91

C L 98

P R 98

P L 102

VIS 53

CLU 90

FLD 64

SPD 51

 

93

Mickey Mantle

Cityscapes | yankees

S/R CF 1B, LF

C R 86

C L 96

P R 90

P L 81

VIS 70

CLU 90

FLD 76

SPD 79

 

93

Giancarlo Stanton

Postseason | yankees

R/R LF RF

Buy 207,997

Sell 182,005

C R 90

C L 95

P R 109

P L 109

VIS 47

CLU 99

FLD 64

SPD 42

 

93

Aaron Judge

Live | yankees

R/R RF CF

Buy 550,000

Sell 490,001

C R 87

C L 87

P R 108

P L 109

VIS 41

CLU 97

FLD 61

SPD 50

 

93

Graig Nettles

Standout | yankees

L/R 3B

C R 100

C L 73

P R 98

P L 77

VIS 83

CLU 90

FLD 86

SPD 47

 

92

CC Sabathia

Mural | yankees

L/L SP

Buy 6,517

Sell 5,000

C R 8

C L 6

P R 6

P L 4

VIS 8

CLU 8

FLD 74

SPD 37

 

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FBSlider SliderCircle Change Circ-ChSinker SinkerCutter Cutter

92

Anthony Volpe

Awards | yankees

R/R SS

Buy 5,691

Sell 5,000

C R 64

C L 88

P R 86

P L 91

VIS 68

CLU 73

FLD 87

SPD 83

 

92

Babe Ruth

Contributor | yankees

L/L LF 1B, RF

Buy 364,000

Sell 283,002

C R 95

C L 90

P R 90

P L 101

VIS 70

CLU 95

FLD 65

SPD 45

 

92

Bernie Williams

2nd Half Heroes | yankees

S/R CF

Buy 41,000

Sell 36,405

C R 109

C L 105

P R 60

P L 90

VIS 86

CLU 107

FLD 61

SPD 65

 

91

Spencer Jones

Topps Now | yankees

L/L RF 1B, LF, CF

C R 96

C L 60

P R 101

P L 83

VIS 52

CLU 88

FLD 73

SPD 80

 

90

Trent Grisham

Topps Now | yankees

L/L CF

Buy 8,788

Sell 5,262

C R 80

C L 65

P R 108

P L 88

VIS 71

CLU 81

FLD 82

SPD 50

 

90

Gerrit Cole

All-Star | yankees

R/R SP

Buy 11,994

Sell 9,601

C R 11

C L 16

P R 32

P L 24

VIS 22

CLU 15

FLD 29

SPD 25

 

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FBSlider SliderKnuckle-curve Kn-CrvCircle Change Circ-ChSinker Sinker

90

Andrew Miller

Veteran | yankees

L/L CP

Buy 64,979

Sell 57,002

C R 11

C L 8

P R 6

P L 4

VIS 9

CLU 7

FLD 65

SPD 38

 

Slider Slider4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FBSinker SinkerCircle Change Circ-Ch

90

Cam Schlittler

Egg Hunt | yankees

R/R SP

Buy 16,390

Sell 14,252

C R 6

C L 7

P R 6

P L 7

VIS 5

CLU 8

FLD 46

SPD 38

 

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FBCutter CutterSlurve SlurveSinker SinkerSweeper Sweep

89

Alfonso Soriano

St. Patrick's Day | yankees

R/R 2B LF

C R 83

C L 94

P R 78

P L 77

VIS 72

CLU 82

FLD 65

SPD 80

 

88

Luis Gil

Awards | yankees

R/R SP

C R 11

C L 15

P R 7

P L 11

VIS 16

CLU 10

FLD 46

SPD 33

 

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FBSlider SliderCircle Change Circ-ChSinker Sinker

88

Phil Rizzuto

Egg Hunt | yankees

R/R SS 2B

C R 100

C L 115

P R 41

P L 40

VIS 107

CLU 95

FLD 90

SPD 83

 

88

George Lombard Jr.

Spring Breakout | yankees

R/R SS 2B, 3B

C R 82

C L 62

P R 72

P L 77

VIS 68

CLU 75

FLD 90

SPD 82