Captain Paul O'Neill info and eligible players - MLB The Show 26

Paul O'Neill

RF

CORE | Jolt | Reds

Not Sellable

Date Added

3-12-26

Where to Get

• Reds Team Affinity

Players from the Cincinnati Reds

• Tier 1 Requires 5 Hitters
• +2 Contact Left
• +2 Contact Right
• +2 Power Left
• +2 Power Right

• Tier 2 Requires 10 Hitters
• +4 Contact Left
• +4 Contact Right
• +4 Power Left
• +4 Power Right

• Tier 3 Requires 15 Hitters
• +6 Contact Left
• +6 Contact Right
• +6 Power Left
• +6 Power Right

97

Justin Lebron

2026 Draft | reds

R/R SS 2B, 3B

Buy 20,000

Sell 17,014

C R 85

C L 92

P R 91

P L 102

VIS 66

CLU 90

FLD 89

SPD 90

 

96

Eric Becker

2026 Draft | reds

L/R SS 2B, 3B

C R 103

C L 95

P R 88

P L 76

VIS 94

CLU 106

FLD 82

SPD 79

 

96

Chase Burns

2026 All-Star | reds

R/R SP

Buy 5,774

Sell 5,001

C R 4

C L 8

P R 3

P L 5

VIS 5

CLU 6

FLD 53

SPD 31

 

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FBSlider SliderCircle Change Circ-ChCurveball CurveSinker Sinker

96

Nick Castellanos

Awards | reds

R/R RF

Buy 7,943

Sell 6,702

C R 107

C L 105

P R 98

P L 105

VIS 77

CLU 103

FLD 56

SPD 69

 

96

Hunter Greene

Summer | reds

R/R SP

Buy 22,550

Sell 17,505

C R 0

C L 0

P R 0

P L 0

VIS 2

CLU 0

FLD 49

SPD 34

 

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FBSlider SliderSplitter SplitSlurve SlurveSinker Sinker

96

Rob Dibble

Summer | reds

L/R RP

C R 13

C L 10

P R 6

P L 2

VIS 8

CLU 6

FLD 42

SPD 27

 

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FBSlider SliderCutter Cutter

95

Sal Stewart

2026 All-Star | reds

R/R 1B 2B, 3B

C R 84

C L 96

P R 86

P L 100

VIS 78

CLU 100

FLD 80

SPD 51

 

95

Tejay Antone

Spotlight | reds

R/R RP

C R 0

C L 0

P R 0

P L 0

VIS 2

CLU 0

FLD 59

SPD 41

 

Sweeper SweepCutter CutterCurveball Curve4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FBSinker Sinker

94

Chase Petty

Topps Now | reds

R/R RP

Buy 4,900

Sell 5,000

C R 6

C L 9

P R 3

P L 6

VIS 11

CLU 10

FLD 44

SPD 39

 

Sinker SinkerCircle Change Circ-Ch4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FBSlider SliderSweeper Sweep

94

Elly De La Cruz

Spotlight | reds

S/R SS

C R 90

C L 95

P R 80

P L 97

VIS 60

CLU 96

FLD 81

SPD 73

 

93

Edwin Arroyo

Topps Now | reds

S/R 2B 3B, SS

Buy 4,999

Sell 5,000

C R 90

C L 95

P R 76

P L 81

VIS 73

CLU 92

FLD 90

SPD 73

 

93

JJ Bleday

Spotlight | reds

L/L RF LF, CF

Buy 6,790

Sell 5,555

C R 81

C L 101

P R 96

P L 81

VIS 76

CLU 106

FLD 71

SPD 64

 

93

Luis Castillo

Vintage | reds

R/R SP

Buy 24,822

Sell 13,681

C R 8

C L 0

P R 0

P L 0

VIS 12

CLU 0

FLD 67

SPD 25

 

Circle Change Circ-Ch4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FBSinker SinkerSlider Slider

91

Barry Larkin

Cityscapes | reds

R/R SS

Buy 7,000

Sell 5,000

C R 90

C L 93

P R 50

P L 65

VIS 100

CLU 93

FLD 85

SPD 92

 

91

Sal Stewart

Spotlight | reds

R/R 1B 2B, 3B

Buy 7,325

Sell 4,500

C R 86

C L 94

P R 76

P L 90

VIS 74

CLU 97

FLD 72

SPD 45

 

90

Johnny Bench

Cityscapes | reds

R/R C 1B, 3B, LF, RF

Buy 3,775

Sell 4,000

C R 77

C L 80

P R 74

P L 83

VIS 82

CLU 80

FLD 86

SPD 48

 

89

Jonathan India

Awards | reds

R/R 2B

Buy 3,975

Sell 3,500

C R 90

C L 109

P R 88

P L 65

VIS 70

CLU 91

FLD 58

SPD 80

 

89

Adam Dunn

St. Patrick's Day | reds

L/R LF 1B

Buy 20,470

Sell 18,083

C R 86

C L 78

P R 110

P L 90

VIS 56

CLU 75

FLD 63

SPD 48

 

89

Eugenio Suárez

World Baseball Classic | reds

R/R 3B

Buy 14,223

Sell 10,051

C R 84

C L 65

P R 106

P L 104

VIS 53

CLU 81

FLD 56

SPD 45

 

88

Paul O'Neill

Jolt | reds

L/L RF 1B

C R 87

C L 57

P R 97

P L 58

VIS 79

CLU 83

FLD 88

SPD 56