Captain Andrew McCutchen info and eligible players - MLB The Show 25

Andrew McCutchen

RF

CORE | Jolt | Pirates

Not Sellable

Date Added

3-14-25

Where to Get

• Team Affinity 1

Players from the Pittsburgh Pirates

• Tier 1 Requires 5 Hitters
• +5 Contact Right
• +5 Contact Left
• +5 Clutch
• +5 H/9

• Tier 2 Requires 12 Hitters
• +8 Contact Right
• +8 Contact Left
• +8 Clutch
• +8 H/9

• Tier 3 Requires 18 Hitters
• +10 Contact Right
• +10 Contact Left
• +10 Clutch
• +10 H/9

99

Oneil Cruz

Captain | pirates

L/R CF SS

C R 120

C L 100

P R 125

P L 115

VIS 80

CLU 115

FLD 90

SPD 97

 

99

Dennis Santana

2025 Finest | pirates

R/R CP

C R 3

C L 3

P R 0

P L 0

VIS 0

CLU 3

FLD 45

SPD 44

 

Slider Slider4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FBCutter CutterSinker SinkerCircle Change Circ-Ch

99

Paul Skenes

2025 Finest | pirates

R/R SP

C R 36

C L 34

P R 22

P L 26

VIS 25

CLU 25

FLD 55

SPD 45

 

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FBSinker SinkerSweeper SweepVulcan Change VulcanSlider Slider

99

Spencer Horwitz

Spotlight | pirates

L/R 1B 2B, LF

C R 125

C L 93

P R 125

P L 87

VIS 104

CLU 117

FLD 84

SPD 45

 

99

Roberto Clemente

Awards | pirates

R/R RF

C R 125

C L 125

P R 91

P L 100

VIS 108

CLU 125

FLD 90

SPD 70

 

99

Bill Mazeroski

Moonshot | pirates

R/R 2B

C R 100

C L 125

P R 117

P L 120

VIS 101

CLU 106

FLD 97

SPD 54

 

99

Honus Wagner

Hall of Fame | pirates

R/R SS 1B, 2B, 3B, LF, CF, RF

Buy 798,999

Sell 525,001

C R 125

C L 125

P R 94

P L 100

VIS 125

CLU 125

FLD 92

SPD 99

 

99

Bryan Reynolds

Neon | pirates

S/R RF LF, CF

C R 120

C L 125

P R 110

P L 102

VIS 92

CLU 125

FLD 91

SPD 86

 

99

Konnor Griffin

Neon | pirates

R/R SS LF, CF, RF

C R 108

C L 105

P R 100

P L 114

VIS 90

CLU 109

FLD 93

SPD 99

 

99

Willie Stargell

Cornerstone | pirates

L/L LF 1B, RF

C R 119

C L 98

P R 120

P L 103

VIS 83

CLU 114

FLD 73

SPD 54

 

99

Dave Parker

Hall of Fame | pirates

L/R RF

C R 120

C L 112

P R 93

P L 90

VIS 103

CLU 120

FLD 82

SPD 74

 

98

Jared Triolo

Spotlight | pirates

R/R SS 1B, 2B, 3B

C R 101

C L 125

P R 72

P L 86

VIS 92

CLU 111

FLD 95

SPD 88

 

98

Oneil Cruz

2025 Home Run Derby | pirates

L/R CF SS

Buy 167,998

Sell 33,322

C R 120

C L 106

P R 120

P L 120

VIS 82

CLU 120

FLD 64

SPD 80

 

97

Hunter Barco

Topps Now | pirates

L/L RP

Buy 38,965

Sell 5,202

C R 6

C L 4

P R 2

P L 6

VIS 4

CLU 3

FLD 45

SPD 55

 

Sinker SinkerSplitter SplitSlider Slider

97

Cam Devanney

Topps Now | pirates

R/R 3B 1B, 2B, SS, LF

Buy 18,999

Sell 5,000

C R 108

C L 103

P R 101

P L 90

VIS 82

CLU 106

FLD 82

SPD 76

 

97

Bubba Chandler

Topps Now | pirates

S/R CP

C R 32

C L 28

P R 32

P L 33

VIS 26

CLU 38

FLD 71

SPD 77

 

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FBSlider SliderCircle Change Circ-Ch12-6 Curve 12-6

97

Liover Peguero

Topps Now | pirates

R/R 1B 2B, SS

C R 92

C L 101

P R 100

P L 106

VIS 77

CLU 104

FLD 75

SPD 88

 

97

Seth Hernandez

2025 Draft | pirates

R/R SP

Buy 60,000

Sell 19,100

C R 3

C L 7

P R 4

P L 7

VIS 6

CLU 7

FLD 58

SPD 26

 

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FBCircle Change Circ-Ch12-6 Curve 12-6Slider Slider2-Seam Fastball 2-SM FB

96

Paul Skenes

2025 All-Star | pirates

R/R SP

C R 36

C L 34

P R 22

P L 26

VIS 25

CLU 25

FLD 55

SPD 45

 

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FBSplitter SplitSweeper SweepVulcan Change VulcanSinker Sinker

95

Dave Parker

2nd Half Heroes | pirates

L/R RF

C R 118

C L 108

P R 86

P L 71

VIS 80

CLU 118

FLD 72

SPD 66