Best First Basemen

Top First Basemen by true rating in MLB The Show 21

Quirks Secondaries
  • Rankings with Quirks ratings. (Estimates how quirks impact a player's overall ability.)
  • Rankings with Secondary Position players
What is True Rating?
BattingHand
#251
Pete Alonso, 83 Live - MLB the Show 21
79.79 TR
Pete Alonso
Stubs -
Stubs -
#252
Eduardo Escobar, 83 Live - MLB the Show 21
79.47 TR
Eduardo Escobar
Stubs -
Stubs -
#253
Brett Baty, 83 Prospect - MLB the Show 21
79.12 TR
Brett Baty
Stubs -
Stubs -
#254
Alex Bregman, 82 Live - MLB the Show 21
79.07 TR
Alex Bregman
Stubs -
Stubs -
#255
Justin Turner, 80 Live - MLB the Show 21
79.05 TR
Justin Turner
Stubs -
Stubs -
#256
Evan Longoria, 81 Live - MLB the Show 21
79.01 TR
Evan Longoria
Stubs -
Stubs -
#257
Frank Schwindel, 82 Live - MLB the Show 21
78.85 TR
Frank Schwindel
Stubs -
Stubs -
#258
Josh Bell, 81 Live - MLB the Show 21
78.68 TR
Josh Bell
Stubs -
Stubs -
#259
Anthony Rizzo, 81 Live - MLB the Show 21
78.56 TR
Anthony Rizzo
Stubs -
Stubs -
#260
Jared Walsh, 81 Live - MLB the Show 21
78.56 TR
Jared Walsh
Stubs -
Stubs -
#261
Edwin Encarnacion, 82 Veteran - MLB the Show 21
78.4 TR
Edwin Encarnacion
Stubs -
Stubs -
#262
Ryan Mountcastle, 81 Live - MLB the Show 21
78.18 TR
Ryan Mountcastle
Stubs -
Stubs -
#263
Yasmani Grandal, 86 All-Star - MLB the Show 21
78.06 TR
Yasmani Grandal
Stubs -
Stubs -
#264
Braden Shewmake, 83 Prospect - MLB the Show 21
77.98 TR
Braden Shewmake
Stubs -
Stubs -
#265
Daniel Vogelbach, 81 Monthly Awards - MLB the Show 21
77.8 TR
Daniel Vogelbach
Stubs -
Stubs -
#266
Matt Carpenter, 81 Veteran - MLB the Show 21
77.66 TR
Matt Carpenter
Stubs -
Stubs -
#267
Jim Thome, 81 Veteran - MLB the Show 21
77.39 TR
Jim Thome
Not Sellable
#268
Wilmer Flores, 76 Live - MLB the Show 21
77.04 TR
Wilmer Flores
Stubs -
Stubs -
#269
Jonathan Lucroy, 85 All-Star - MLB the Show 21
77 TR
Jonathan Lucroy
Not Sellable
#270
Ivan Rodriguez, 84 Veteran - MLB the Show 21
76.99 TR
Ivan Rodriguez
Not Sellable
#271
Jonathan Schoop, 80 Live - MLB the Show 21
76.98 TR
Jonathan Schoop
Stubs -
Stubs -
#272
Jesus Aguilar, 79 Live - MLB the Show 21
76.83 TR
Jesus Aguilar
Stubs -
Stubs -
#273
Ken Griffey Sr., 79 Veteran - MLB the Show 21
76.8 TR
Ken Griffey Sr.
Stubs -
Stubs -
#274
Mike Moustakas, 78 Live - MLB the Show 21
76.73 TR
Mike Moustakas
Stubs -
Stubs -
#275
Tommy La Stella, 76 Live - MLB the Show 21
76.68 TR
Tommy La Stella
Stubs -
Stubs -

Best First Basemen in MLB The Show 21 - Insights

Milestone Willie Mays holds the top spot among the best First Basemen with an impressive 114.20 True Rating.

Right behind Willie Mays are Milestone Albert Pujols and Milestone Lou Gehrig, forming a strong top group. Overall, the top 10 MLB First Basemen average a 111.99 True Rating.

Finest Vladimir Guerrero Jr. is notable within the top 5 for benefiting significantly from 3 active quirks.