Best Catchers

Top Catchers by true rating in MLB The Show 25

On this page:

Quirks Secondaries
  • Rankings with Quirks ratings. (Estimates how quirks impact a player's overall ability.)
  • Rankings with Secondary Position players
What is True Rating?
BattingHand
#1
Mike Piazza, 92 All-Star - MLB the Show 25
92.68 TR
Mike Piazza
Stubs 35,245
Stubs 32,201
#2
Jorge Posada, 92 Standout - MLB the Show 25
92.33 TR
Jorge Posada
Stubs 167,994
Stubs 140,333
#3
Ted Simmons, 90 Awards - MLB the Show 25
91.36 TR
Ted Simmons
Not Sellable
#4
Carlos Santana, 92 Spotlight - MLB the Show 25
91.17 TR
Carlos Santana
Not Sellable
#5
Willson Contreras, 91 Spotlight - MLB the Show 25
89.09 TR
Willson Contreras
Stubs 32,495
Stubs 28,600
#6
Yasmani Grandal, 91 Moonshot - MLB the Show 25
89.03 TR
Yasmani Grandal
Not Sellable
#7
Cal Raleigh, 89 Spotlight - MLB the Show 25
88.53 TR
Cal Raleigh
Stubs 34,994
Stubs 31,605
#8
Jonah Heim, 90 Awards - MLB the Show 25
88.24 TR
Jonah Heim
Stubs 68,395
Stubs 56,000
#9
Mike Napoli, 88 Contributor - MLB the Show 25
88.21 TR
Mike Napoli
Not Sellable
#10
Josh Gibson, 90 The Negro Leagues - MLB the Show 25
88.05 TR
Josh Gibson
Stubs 39,994
Stubs 33,635
#11
Sean Murphy, 89 Moonshot - MLB the Show 25
87.17 TR
Sean Murphy
Stubs 14,330
Stubs 11,976
#12
Shea Langeliers, 87 Egg Hunt - MLB the Show 25
86.86 TR
Shea Langeliers
Stubs 2,600
Stubs 2,251
#13
Logan O'Hoppe, 87 Egg Hunt - MLB the Show 25
86.83 TR
Logan O'Hoppe
Not Sellable
#14
Ivan Rodriguez, 86 2nd Half Heroes - MLB the Show 25
86.83 TR
Ivan Rodriguez
Stubs 2,688
Stubs 1,891
#15
Jason Varitek, 87 Breakout - MLB the Show 25
86.56 TR
Jason Varitek
Stubs 9,195
Stubs 7,514
#16
Joey Bart, 87 Moonshot - MLB the Show 25
86.1 TR
Joey Bart
Stubs 2,999
Stubs 2,509
#17
Johnny Bench, 86 Jolt - MLB the Show 25
85.81 TR
Johnny Bench
Not Sellable
#18
Drake Baldwin, 88 Topps Now - MLB the Show 25
85.63 TR
Drake Baldwin
Stubs 7,282
Stubs 6,075
#19
Will Smith, 86 Live - MLB the Show 25
85.12 TR
Will Smith
Stubs 4,498
Stubs 3,890
#20
Carson Kelly, 86 Topps Now - MLB the Show 25
84.86 TR
Carson Kelly
Not Sellable
#21
Samuel Basallo, 87 Pipeline - MLB the Show 25
84.82 TR
Samuel Basallo
Stubs 6,969
Stubs 5,686
#22
Craig Biggio, 85 Jolt - MLB the Show 25
84.69 TR
Craig Biggio
Not Sellable
#23
Gary Sánchez, 86 New Threads - MLB the Show 25
84.65 TR
Gary Sánchez
Stubs 5,099
Stubs 4,405
#24
Tyler Soderstrom, 88 Spotlight - MLB the Show 25
84.57 TR
Tyler Soderstrom
Stubs 27,890
Stubs 22,100
#25
Joe Torre, 85 Egg Hunt - MLB the Show 25
84.55 TR
Joe Torre
Stubs 1,700
Stubs 1,500

Best Catchers in MLB The Show 25 - Insights

All-Star Mike Piazza holds the top spot among the best Catchers with an impressive 92.68 True Rating, and is also the most recent addition to the top 10, released 10 hours ago.

Right behind Mike Piazza are Standout Jorge Posada and Awards Ted Simmons, forming a strong top group. Overall, the top 10 MLB Catchers average a 89.87 True Rating.

Standout Jorge Posada currently the most expensive player available on the market among the top 5, costing around 167,994 stubs.

Awards Ted Simmons is notable within the top 5 for benefiting significantly from 8 active quirks.

Egg Hunt Logan O'Hoppe is a top free option, ranked #13. This card can be acquired from the Egg Hunt Program.